Can I Use Olive Oil Instead of Vegetable Oil

Can I Use Olive Oil Instead of Vegetable Oil

Can I Use Olive Oil Instead of Vegetable Oil

Sometimes, we have all been in a situation where we pick up a recipe book and stare at a recipe that calls for vegetable oil. Then we glance at that beautiful bottle of olive oil, wondering if they can be used interchangeably. This thought is common among home cooks worldwide, from bustling city apartments to cosy cabins. We acknowledge that everyone wants to make wise health choices. When preparing a meal, you will also choose the best oil for taste and health.

Can you use olive oil as a substitute for vegetable oil? Yes, you can, but there are a few essential things to consider before making that change in cooking.

Understanding Olive and Vegetable Oils

Before considering whether we can use one oil instead of another, let's ensure we understand the properties of olive and vegetable oils and how they enhance our dishes. 

What is Vegetable Oil

When a recipe calls for vegetable oil, it's usually a general term for an oil made from seeds. In Canada, some of the most commonly used ones include canola oil made from rapeseed. It has a mild taste and is suitable for cooking at high temperatures.

Other vegetable oils include corn oil, which comes from corn and has a neutral taste. Soybean oil, from soybeans, is another widely used vegetable oil. And then there's sunflower oil, which comes from sunflower seeds and is also relatively neutral in flavour.

The main feature of these vegetable oils is that they generally taste very mild. This is best for cooking, as these oils won't change the flavour of your food much. This is one of the primary reasons many people consider them for cooking, where the oil shouldn't add any taste.

They also tend to have a high smoke point and are cheaper to buy. These qualities make vegetable oil a common choice for everyday cooking, especially for items that require deep-frying or stir-frying large batches of food.

What is Olive Oil

Olive oil is manufactured by pressing olives, which are small fruits full of nutrients! As this oil comes from a fruit, it naturally has more flavour and a richer feel than other vegetable seed oils.

There are different types of olive oil, and knowing them helps you choose the right one for your cooking.

The top-quality choice is Extra Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO) from The Spice Trader. This oil is made from the finest pressing of the olives without using heat or chemicals. It has an intense, fruity, or grassy flavour and a lower smoke point than other oils.

Moreover, there's Regular Olive Oil called pure olive oil. This is a blend of refined olive oil and virgin or extra virgin olive oil for flavour. The refining process makes it lighter in colour and milder in flavour, and gives it a higher smoke point than EVOO. It's important to remember that light, in this case, means light in taste and colour, not lighter in calories!

Can You Use One Instead of the Other?

Yes, in most cases, you can use olive oil instead of vegetable oil. However, replacing one oil with another isn't always a simple swap if you want the best results for your dish. Some dishes call for mild or plain oil flavours that don't impact the overall taste. 

The Difference Between Olive and Vegetable Oils

Let's look at the main differences between these oils to decide if using olive oil instead of vegetable oil is a good idea for your specific cooking. These differences will guide your choice, as many individuals do not like the taste of olive oil in their meals.

Flavour Profile

This is the most significant difference you will notice immediately in your food. Vegetable oil is usually very neutral, making it a popular choice for baking or frying foods where you don't want any extra oil flavour interfering with the main ingredients.

Olive oil, on the other hand, has a noticeable flavour. Extra Virgin olive oil has a strong, fresh, often slightly peppery or grassy taste. Even regular olive oil carries that unique olive flavour.

So, first, consider what you are making. If you're baking delicate, fluffy cupcakes, you probably wouldn't want them to taste faintly of olives. But if you're roasting green vegetables or making a Mediterranean-inspired dressing, that olive flavour could be an excellent addition to enhance the flavour of your dish.

Smoke Point

The smoke point of oils is simply the temperature at which an oil starts to smoke, break down, and produce unhealthy substances. When oil starts smoking, it also tastes quite bad and can even ruin your food.

Vegetable oils like canola, corn, or sunflower oil have high smoke points, typically ranging from around 204°C to 232°C. This characteristic makes them a safe and reliable choice for high-heat cooking methods like deep-frying, quick stir-frying, or searing meats.

However, EVOO has a lower smoke point, usually around 170°C to 210°C, so it's not the best choice for high-heat cooking. It will smoke and burn more easily, ruining the flavour of your food and creating undesirable and unhealthy substances.

Regular olive oil has a higher smoke point than EVOO, which usually starts at 216°C as it has been refined. This makes it a better option for higher-heat cooking than Extra Virgin, but it's generally not as robust as some common vegetable oils for extreme heat.

So, if you're deep-frying chips, you will need very hot oil. Extra Virgin Olive Oil will start smoking and burning long before your chips are cooked, and the flavour will be unpleasant. For everyday cooking, such as gentle sauteing or oven roasting, regular olive oil is excellent and works very well.

Cost

Vegetable oils are usually much cheaper to buy by the bottle, offering a budget-friendly option for everyday cooking. On the other hand, olive oils are more expensive, with good quality Extra Virgin Olive Oil being the priciest.

If you are cooking something following a recipe that calls for a large amount of oil, such as a big batch of deep-fried chicken or a big tray of oven chips, using expensive olive oil may not be the most economical choice. For significant quantities, always go for a more budget-friendly vegetable.

Nutritional Differences

Olive oil, especially Extra Virgin, is well-known and celebrated for being rich in monounsaturated fats, which are considered good fats and are suitable for heart health. Olive oil is also packed with antioxidants, which are great for keeping your body healthy and active.

However, regarding vegetable oils, canola oil is also high in monounsaturated fats, similar to olive oil. Other common vegetable oils, like sunflower or corn oil, might have more polyunsaturated fats, particularly omega-6 fatty acids. While polyunsaturated fats are also essential for your body's health, it is generally good to have a balance of different types of fats in your diet.

Overall, olive oil, especially Extra Virgin, is considered a healthier choice due to its unique beneficial compounds and favourable fat profile.

Conclusion

For many dishes, especially those involving sauteing, roasting, or creating delicious dressings and marinades, olive oil is a viable substitute and often a superior choice. It brings wonderful flavour and significant health benefits to your cooking. Just remember to think about the flavour of the oil and its smoke point, depending on how you plan to cook.

Don't be afraid to get creative in your kitchen! Your kitchen is your space for trying new dishes, adding or subtracting new ingredients, and understanding the unique qualities of different oils, which gives you the power to make tastier, healthier, and more intentional daily choices. Head over to a quality shop like The Spice Trader to explore their range of oils, and let your amazing cooking adventures truly begin!

Back to top
Free Shipping CANADA wide over $100 ( not including territories)